Saturday 5 November 2016

A Memorandum submitted to Shri Jual Oram, the Honourable Minister of Tribal Welfare Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi on 25-10-2016

TIPRALAND STATE PARTY
(TSP)
                                                                  Address:-
Old kalibari Road, Krishnanagr,
West Tripura District,  Agartala-799001.
Email: tipralandsp@gmail.com
936588346(M)
Date: 25 -10-2016.
To
The Honorable  Minister for Tribal Welfare Affairs of India
Government of India
New Delhi.


Sub:- Memorandum on the demand for Statehood of TTAAC.


Respected Sir,

                   The tribes in Tripura, are demanding elevation of Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council (TTAADC) to Tipraland State. We have been launching movements peacefully and democratically in the State of Tripura. Now, we  are on Sit-in-Demonstration here from October 26-27, 2016 at Jantar-Mantar, New Delhi in support of our demand. We do have full faith in the Constitution of India.
Demographic Invasion during 1947-1951
Sensing imminent partition of India, 4600 fled to Tripura ( the then Hill Tipperah) from East Bengal in 1946. Thereafter, an acute demographic invasion had taken place due partition of India since 1947 itself from East Pakistan i.e; erstwhile East Bengal. The 1951 Census was far from accurate as the enumerators could not collect data for it. However,  based on the data of 1951 Census, it can derived that the total population of Tripura without refugees was 375,303. The total population of tribes and non-tribes was 237,953 and 132,750(without refugees) respectively. While the total population of refugees ( 1946 to 1951) was sheltered in Tripura was 284004. The total population including refugees,  as per 1951 Census was  654,707. The  population of  tribes  without refugees was 63.40%. The  population of  tribes  including refugees was 36.34%. It was almost as soon as Tripura merged with Indian dominion within less than 3(three) years; the population of tribes that was commanding majority had witnessed vigorous demographic invasion. The population of tribes without refugees would have been about 90%.  The household to household enumeration which could not be held due to remoteness and far flung areas in the State. There was a habit of frequent shifting amongst the tribes households from one place to the other. The percentage of the population of refugees from East Pakistan was 284,004 which constituted  43.38%  of total population in 1951 Census. The total(!) population of refugees and  tribes was 284,004(43.38%) and  237,953(36.34%) respectively. The total population of refugees was more than the total population of the tribes in Tripura. The partition of India in 1947 had not shattered any other States by a demographic invasion as it had created a gigantic impact upon Tripura by a way of socio-economic and political too. The tribes of Tripura is making every effort as it is pushing them edged end of wall for their extinction. It may kindly be noted that the population of the tribes in Tripura was reduced to marginally minority within less than 3(three) years from the date (15-10-1949) of  Tripura’s merger with Indian Union.
Refugees outnumbered  Population of tribes in Tripura by the 1951 Census: The Statement of  Pt. Govinda Bhallav Pant, Former Minister of India in 1956.
In the forgoing para above, it is clear that the refugees was coming from East Pakistan (erstwhile East Bengal)  in to Tripura just before and from 1947 to 1951due to partition of India itself had outnumbered the population of tribes who were majority in the State within a span of less than three years from the date Tripura merged with India on 15-10-1949. Pt. Govinda Bhallav Pant said, “Tripura by now is supersaturated in terms of population. Not a single refugee could further be accommodated in Tripura State.” Yet the inflow of refugees from East Pakistan continued in Tripura till it gained independence in 1971 and thereafter as illegal migrants till date. Lt. Gen (Rtd.) S.K.Sinha, PVSM said, “The unabated influx of illegal migrants from Bangladesh in to Assam and the consequence perceptible change in demographic pattern of the state, has been a matter of grave concern. It threatens to reduce Assamese people to a minority in their own state, as happened in Tripura and Sikkim.” Therefore, demographic invasion over the population of the tribes in Tripura is uninterrupted and rapidly pushing them to the edge wall of extinction. In order to save them from extinction, we demand elevation of TTAADC to “Tipraland State” under Article 3 of the Constitution of India.
The Influx of Refugees Continued
The total number of refugees during the period of 1952-1958 was 190,000; the registration of refugees was discontinued during 1959-1963; the influx of the refugees during 1964-1971 was 140,594 and Tripura had in total 614,598 in 26 years; that was  from 1946 to 1971. It was an uninterrupted flow of refugees in Tripura State.  Perhaps, no other tiny State other than Tripura State in India which had to encounter such demographic invasion resulting sharp decline in the population of the tribes that face extinct today. This demographic invasion has been taking place since the partition of India. Therefore, we are the victims with cascading effects of the of the partition of India in 1947 and subsequently,  the victim of Bangladesh Liberation War ending in 1971. This was the lone reason for the tribes in Tripura to become marginal minority today. The influx of refugees from the year 1947 to 1951 was landmark that the demographic invasion against the tribes in Tripura resulted that they reduced to microscopic  minority. There is no other option or alternative before us but to demand for elevation of TTAADC to a full-fledged “Tipraland” statehood within the framework and under Article-3 of the Constitution of India for the fact that the population of our tribes will get reduced to insignificant percentage or to the state of extinction in the next two decade or so from now. Had there been no such enormous influx of refugees in the State of Tripura, the present demand for Tipraland State would in no way  have arisen.

The Expectation of the Tribes in Tripura
Tripura merged with Indian Union for the safeguards of its people; especially the tribes who were majority before her merger. We are safe in the hands of the Government of India with the issuance of  NOTIFICATION vide No.221P, dated 15-10-1949 in  the Ministry of States dt. 15-10-1949 in which para-5 says, “Existing laws to continue:- All laws in force in Tripura or any part thereof immediately before the commencement of this Order shall continue in force until repealed or amended by a competent legislature or authority;
Provided that all powers exercisable under the said laws by His Highness the Maharaja or the Government of the State shall be exercisable by the Chief Commissioner.”
This notification was relevant, especially in relation to the reservation of land made by His Highness Maharaja in 1931 and 1943 for five communities, namely; Tripura, Reang Jamatia, Noatia and Halam. The total land reserved was 2060 square miles. The said reserved land was repealed by the Government to facilitate rehabilitation of refugees in 1974. There was gigantic pressure upon the all resources in Tripura due high refugee influx and it continues with illegal infiltration in the State. This has created a clear concept in the minds of  tribes that they are going to extinct gradually without safeguards under the Article-3 of the Constitution of India without the elevation of TTAADC to a full-fledged State a right of self determination by elevation of  TTAADC to a full-fledged State “Tipraland” under Article-3 of the Constitution of  India.                                                        Table-1
The Influx of Refugees in Tripura from 1947 to 1971
Years(s)
No. of refugees registered
Population of tribes
Population of Non-tribes
Total
(Including Refugees)
1
2
3
4
5
1946
(A)
4,600
-
-
This was not reflected  in the registration.
1947-51
(B)
279,404
-
-
(A)+(B)
284,004
(43.38)***
237,953
*(64.19) & (36.34)**
132,750
*(35.81) &(20.96)**
654,707
(as per 1951 Census)
1952-58
190,000
360,070
*(53.53) & (31.53)**
312,531
*(47.47) & (27.37)**
11,42,005
(as per 1961 Census)
Sub-Total
(C)
474,404
(41.54)***
1959-63
Registration of Refugees discontinued

1964-71
(D)
140,594

450,544
*(47.61) & (28.95)**

495,800
*(52.39) & (31.86)**

15,56,342
( as per 1971 Census)

Total of (A)  & (B) of Col. 2
614,598
(39.48)***
N.B:- Figure in the parenthesis indicate percentage. * (one esterric) indicate percentage of of the population of tribes & non-tribes excluding the population of refugees and **(two esteric) indicate the percentage of population of the tribes and non-tribes including the population of the refugees.
Source:- Author Gayatri Bhattacharyya in her book titled “Refugee Rehabilitation and its Impact on Tripura’s Economy”, Omsons Publication, Guwahati, 1988, p.14. (Whatever data available with us is reproduced for us & the objective to reflect the tribes were demographically invaded and reduced to microscopic minority in Tripura )

The above information on refugees in Tripura since the Partition of India in 1947 and the first concluded Population Census in 1951 in the State clearly stated that the population of tribes was 63.40% excluding the population of the refugees from East Pakistan (erstwhile East Bengal) but they were 36.34% taking account of the refugee population.
The Continuous inflow of Illegal Migrants in to Tripura even after 1971:

Tripura has been experiencing illegal intrusions occurring even after cut off date 24th March, 1971. The cases of illegal migration from Bangladesh has surfaced through a seminar paper on “Politics around illegal migration from Bangladesh: With special reference to Assam and Tripura”  submitted  by Shri Minal Kanti Deb and Dr. Arabindo Mahato in the National Seminar on Issues, Challenges & Development held on September 11-12, 2015; organized by Rajiv Gandhi University Research Scholars Forum in collaboration with Department of Political Science, RGU. The proceedings of the paper has been published by the Authors Press: ISBN 978-93-5207-161-6: Q-2A Hauz  Khas Enclave, New Delhi-1100016. The said seminar paper stated that a horrible statistics is being indicated in case of Tripura, the number of illegal migrants had managed to entered was 800,000 and 325,400 in 2001. There has been estimation of the  illegal migration from Bangladesh in Tripura who are either residing in the State illegally by acquiring documents legally by illegal means:  However, this is supplemented with some more data in a tabular form which is given below:-
Table-2
No. of illegal migrants (Voters) legalized by the Election Commission of India
Estimated illegal migrants
Year
Remarks
135,000
Not Available
1994
These illegal voters were detected through the mechanism of Election Commission of India
Not Available
800,000
1998*

Not Available
325,500
2001*

Not Available
65,000**

**Reported by www. tripurainfo.com on 19-02-2016.
N.B:-*Politics around illegal migration from Bangladesh: With special reference to Assam and Tripura -  Minal Kanti Deb and Dr. Arabindo Mahato in the National Seminar on Issues, Challenges & Development held on September 11-12, 2015; organized by RGU Research Scholars Forum in collaboration with Department of Political Science, RGU. 1998. (Whatever data available with us is reproduced for us & the objective to reflect the tribes were demographically invaded and reduced to microscopic minority in Tripura )


The plight of 135,000 illegal voters in Tripura was detected by the Election Commission of India in 1993-94 but they had been enrolled in the Electoral Roll finally.
It is clear that the extent of corruption in regards to providing citizenship in this State of Tripura, while there was no witness of push-back in to Bangladesh. Therefore, there is uninterrupted flow of illegal migrants in the State.  The irony is; the illegal migrants are living in the State under the guise of language and cultural affinity and under the patronage of the political in power; which the Government of Tripura is definitely aware about it but is not paying any heed to it for the reasons best known to it. Therefore, illegal migration is continuing even after the cut off date (24-03-1971) as per Indira-Mujib Pact. We are certain that the numbers of such illegal migrants are yet to have an actual estimation in Tripura. The numbers would be more than what has been revealed in the said seminar paper as submitted by those scholars. The amendment of the Citizenship Act, 1955 is imminent by the both houses of Parliament. Perhaps; the Government of Tripura might come up with the estimated figures of illegal migrants after the amendment of the Citizenship Act, 1955; or they will be granted citizenships silently and without notice.

The Truth on the Actual % of the Tribes in Tripura:
An all party meeting was organized by the Government of Tripura on the issues of the development of tribes in Tripura which was held on February 26, 1992. It was just a year after the population census 1991 concluded. The representative of the then opposition Party in the Tripura Legislative Assembly submitted a written statement submitted in the said meeting. The points; inter-alia of the said submitted statement were  the population of tribes was 23% in the State; the illegal intruders should be confined in a camp and be deported; intrusion of illegal Bangladeshis in TTAADC areas should be prevented in order that the population of tribes was not reduced; and Inner line Permit should be introduced in TTAADC. It may kindly be noted that the  % of tribes in the State was shown to be 28.5% in 1991 Census. In other words; the reality was that the matter concoction of determining the percentage of tribes surfaced to the opposition political party. The Government of Tripura could sense its implication. Although the actual percentage was 23; but to burry the issue; the percentage of tribes in 1991 census was settled at 28.5%. When the actual % tribes was 23% according to 1991 census; then we subsequent two more censuses in 2001 and 2011. Since the actual percentage of Tribes in Tripura was 23 in 1991; taking in to consideration of the said above estimated illegal migration in 1998 and 2001; of course, the trend of illegal migrants from Bangladesh continues even thereafter; the present % of the tribes population in Tripura should even be less than 17. 135,000 illegal voters in Tripura was detected by the Election Commission of India in 1994 but they had been enrolled in the Electoral Roll finally. Therefore, the tribes of Tripura were pushed towards another step to insignificant; their existence need to be safeguarded within the framework of the Constitution of India. Therefore, we demand elevation of TTAADC to Tipraland State under  Article-3 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, it is not difficult to perceive the % of the tribes will get reduced when illegal migrants are legalized and granted citizenship after the proposed amendment of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

Demand for Elevation of TTAADC to Tipraland State
The population of the tribes of Tripura has been invaded demographically by the refugees population of East Pakistan (erstwhile East Bengal) & presently Bangladesh for more than 68 years for the reasons known best to the world and the Government of India as to how they are reduced to marginal minority in their own land on which their 184 kings ruled before merger with India. We place our demand  before your Excellency;  the head of authorities of the Government of India to grant our demand and save us from  both the demographic invasion and extinction -  as within the areas of the Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council(TTAADC), the percentage  of the population of tribes is presently constituted at 84%. The Government of Tripura in association of TTAADC is giving land allotment to the non-tribes within TTAADC areas. The purpose is to reduce or bring down the percentage of tribes population for letting the Sixth Schedule lose its relevancy. The State is working out to achieve this goal. The achievement of this goal would imply that the tribes would lose the right to demand for safeguards under the Article-3 of the Constitution of India; because the population of the tribes in TTAADC will lose  majority by then. This is a wake up call for the Government of India to provide safeguards to the tribes in Tripura by granting Tipraland State. The centre of our focal point should be on development activities; but after extinction of these tribes; development activities should be for whom?  Therefore, the Government of India must grant constitutional safeguards to the tribes in Tripura by way of elevation of the TTAADC to a full fledged State “Tipraland” under Article-3 of the Constitution of India.

Yours faithfully

 Sd/- 25/10/2015

( Chitta Ranjan Debbarma, President, TSP)

N.B:- Missing link of data (if any ) will be supplemented as & when relevant data could be accessed.